2

Currently, we have an tag which is to be utilized for questions about which topics are, well, allowed:

Questions about which topics are permitted / in scope on this site.

However, the tag encompasses this already:

This tag is for questions regarding off topic questions, including whether a question is on topic and what to do with off topic questions. [1]

Doesn't this make the tag redundant?

1: Emphasis mine.

1
  • I also noticed that there's an acceptable-questions tag, perhaps this is redundant too? I can create a separate post with a proposition for reducing redundancy, but it will depend on the answer to this question. Commented Jun 3, 2022 at 19:15

1 Answer 1

4

I think there is some overlap between the two and they should be separate, with some better wording and usage rules in their respective tag wikis and excerpts.

The tag should refer to discussions on off-topic subjects specifically. and the tag excerpt probably need to be better worded. Examples of use may be why something might be considered off-topic or why something should be considered off-topic. Such as is this topic in scope of what the site and users can reasonably handle.

While we have had questions in the past related to law and copyright in terms of anime, such discussions are generally considered off-topics as we are not experts in the area and cannot offer adequate advice. Same thing with creating our own anime/manga as the process varies by country and publisher. Also reading/watching recommendations, as they tend of be very subjective, different people have different tastes.

The tag should cover discussion on what we allow and don't allow, specifically. Like links to 3rd party scanlation sites that may violate copyright, or graphic/pornographic content. For an example, the discussion on the topic of "hentai" is allowed, but graphic content from hentai is not allowed (with restrictions) unless it it required to prove a specific point (i.e., not how it for the) sake of showing it).

The tag on meta should most likely be synonymized with .

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .