6

I recently flagged this question for not being suitable for Anime and Manga Stack Exchange, however, with recent edits, this question does seem on-topic although I cannot really tell if it is.

enter image description here

This was the original post. Based off the confusing wording, one would think that this was an identification request about an image they saw of an oni with a dragon wrapped around them. Based off the edits made by Aki Tanaka, this was not the intent of the post and was only off-topic due to bad/confusing wording.

enter image description here

This is the post now. Although still closed, it seems generally on topic for Anime and Manga Stack Exchange, and does seem like it should be re-opened.

So, is the new post (edited) allowed and on-topic on Anime and Manga Stack Exchange? Or should it (and will it) remain closed?

EDIT!

This question has been officially deleted by reasons of moderation. It cannot be viewed unless you can see deleted posts.

4

The rephrasing definitely helps this question to the point I would not consider it a Identification request anymore. However the question seems to pose several different questions, which would make it a fairly broad question which could probably best be split into 2 separate questions.

The questions as posed by the OP in the question:

  1. What is the name of this trope:

I'm trying to get a better grasp on oni symbolism and references, and "oni with a dragon wrapped around their torso" is something I can't find anything about.

  1. What is the meaning of a dragon wrapped around the torso / what does a oni with a dragon around it's waist symbolize?

I'm looking for what it means if an oni has a dragon wrapped around their torso

  1. What is the origin of oni with a dragon wrapped around them

Question title: What is the origin of oni with a dragon wrapped around them?

Looking at these questions my suggestion would be to combine 1 & 3 into a question:

  • What is the name of this trope, and where does it come from.

asking for trope origins and asking for trope names is generally considered on topic.

And a questions that's more focused on /

  • What does a dragon wrapped around the torso Symbolize

or given that the op is specifically looking for it's symbolism in combinations with demons (oni)

  • What does a dragon wrapped around the torso of an oni symbolize?

Which also is generally considered on topic

6
  • Yeah, thanks for claryfying that. You're right that the question is kind of asking multiple things at once (which I didn't notice, being an idiot) which should be separated into different questions. Still make a good point, +1 & accept. May 18 at 14:25
  • I just noticed that the question garnered 3 upvotes (OP rep 31) but the overall score of question is 0. Why? [cc @ᴅᴀɴɪᴇʟ] May 19 at 6:14
  • No clue. I don't (completely) understand how this site functions, only being here for about 51 days in UTC. May be a glitch, but I'm assuming 3 people who saw it as off-topic downvoted it. Then after it was edited to what seems on-topic, it gained 3 upvotes. May 19 at 11:07
  • 3
    @FumikageTokoyami ᴅᴀɴɪᴇʟッ is correct. The question currently has 3 upvotes and 3 downvotes. Once you have 1000 rep, you'll gain the privilege of being able to view a question's upvotes/downvotes. More information here: anime.stackexchange.com/help/privileges/established-user
    – W. Are
    May 19 at 14:06
  • @FumikageTokoyami the accounts been deleted. Clicking the link you gave will lead to nowhere :/ not sure when or why but that's that May 30 at 12:09
  • @ᴅᴀɴɪᴇʟ Thanks for the update. May 30 at 12:54

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .