When asking a question about the difference between the manga and anime, I would have never thought to use the variations tag. Can we create a synonym of this tag as anime-manga-difference, or at least differences?
-
1Can we just burninate the whole tag? Who would 'follow' or 'ignore' this tag? It seems like a clear meta-tag. Shouldn't this information be in the titles, rather than the tag? More here, at the original meta discussion.– KiruwaDec 14, 2012 at 20:20
-
Marking as declined for lack of a better status because we did away with the variations tag long ago and so this request doesn't really make sense anymore.– senshinMay 1, 2015 at 22:45
Add a comment
|
2 Answers
I'm not a fan of anime-manga-difference. Of the 9 questions tagged as this, 4 of them aren't about comparing anime and manga. It would quickly get out of hand if we had tags for every pair such as light-novel-anime-difference,anime-movie-difference, visual-novel-live-action-difference (okay maybe the last one is unlikely, but you get the picture). Furthermore, it's not clear what should be done if there are 2 different versions of the anime. If I wanted to ask what the differences are between Eat-Man '97 and Eat-Man '98, would I use the tag anime-anime-differences? That's just silly.
I don't have a strong feeling one way for differences vs. variations, but it's not clear to me that the former is more intuitive than the latter. I'd be very surprised if new users use the correct tag regardless of which we choose. From a practical standpoint, I'm just slightly in favor of keeping the status-quo, simply because people are already using it and may not notice the switch.
-
Agree, except for 'people are already using it' -> 'A select group of private beta testers are using it' :) They can manage to deal with this!– VegerDec 14, 2012 at 19:52
-
@Veger That's why it's only a very slight difference. If we had already started public beta, I'd be quite a bit less willing to switch without a good argument.– Logan MDec 14, 2012 at 19:55
-
I don't see
variationsbeing really clear, well actually it makes no sense to me. I would agree ondifferences, that does express "difference".– AlenannoDec 14, 2012 at 22:52
Honestly the anime-manga-difference tag looks like should be the main one to me. variations is quite unclear.
In any case, no-one can create synonyms yet, since according to the Privileges page, we need 1250 reputation.
