3

When I was asking a question about Bleach (the anime), I wanted to use/create the tag, as I wanted to point out that the question was about the anime and not the manga.

I got the error that the anime tag is not allowed. Which is understandable (at first), but in this situation I suppose it was legit to use!

I suppose the same goes for the tag..?

My suggestion is to do allow these tags, so people are able to specify/narrow down about what they are talking.

Edit: I just see that the tag, is being allowed?

11

So, after conferring with the team, I changed my mind. We're going to allow for both and because they would allow for users to filter questions better, and to allow for specific canon references.

That said: I think it would be better if we treated tags the same as on Science Fiction and Fantasy, where you can just state in the question that this is about the Star Wars movie, or a specific Star Wars book, etc. The tag would be and the question body specifies canon.

  • 1
    Someone who is only interested in anime/manga would be grateful to be able to filter out the anime/manga tag in the question overview. So by using these tags it is possible for such users. Adding -anime or -manga to the tags could help as well. – Veger Dec 11 '12 at 21:41
  • @Veger I disagree -- I think most people who are looking for info about Bleach will be able to filter out anime-only stuff from the manga without too much trouble. I don't think we need -manga and -anime tags. – Aarthi Dec 11 '12 at 21:45
  • It is not about beach, but about the -anime and -manga tags in generic. For example, I am not interested in manga (much), so I would like to filter manga specific questions using manga or -manga tags. – Veger Dec 11 '12 at 22:12
  • With respect to your new/updated answer: You are saying the anime and manga tags are allowed, but discouraged? (as it is favored to specify in the question) – Veger Dec 11 '12 at 22:24
  • @Veger I'm saying they are allowed, but I personally don't think we need them. I'm letting the community decide. – Aarthi Dec 11 '12 at 22:25
  • Ok, clear to me – Veger Dec 11 '12 at 22:26
6

I think this is a horrible idea. I can all-but-guarantee you it will become the most-overused and abused tags on the site.

Questions tagged
This tag indicates that the question is specific to the anime version of a series that exists as both anime and manga, or movie(s).

I get that some questions are about an anime-specific version of the work — so describe that in your question; not with tags. Otherwise, we'd have a tag on our Movie & TV site used only for movies that just happen to have TV versions. Sound silly, doesn't it?

Users are never going to understand that an tag is only for questions that are specific to the anime-version of a series that exists as both anime and manga. Users are going to try and use this for every question that is either anime or menga.

But your can't divide a site into large swaths like this. These discussions go back as far back as our Cooking site when some folks were only interested in "savory vs. sweet" while another wanted "vegetarian vs. non-vegetarian." The tags will convey no useful information. At best it will be a horribly incomplete categorization system.

  • I see no problem in having two tags (anime and manga) that are the most extensively used in the site (about half the questions for each, let's assume). – JNat Dec 12 '12 at 16:34
  • Yeah, you're right. Even at this early stage, usage is completely off the rails, with two questions having no descriptive tags beyond "anime". Destroyed and blacklisted. – Shog9 Dec 14 '12 at 2:33
  • @Shog9 Please change the status tag of this thread so other users aren't completely confused when they see it is blacklisted even though the request to blacklist is marked as "declined" – atlantiza Dec 14 '12 at 4:24
  • @atlantiza: read the question carefully: the suggestion was "do allow these tags, so people are able to specify/narrow down about what they are talking." – Shog9 Dec 14 '12 at 4:25
  • @Shog9 Sorry, I was confused since the title seemed to imply that they are requesting to blacklist it; it looks like the mods declined the suggestion of "not allowing" the anime tag. Can we change the title then, to something like "Allow anime tag"? – atlantiza Dec 14 '12 at 4:28
  • @atlantiza: sure. – Shog9 Dec 14 '12 at 4:29
  • @Shog9 Well the manga tag is still allowed so it probably shouldn't be in the title now... Sorry to bother you, and thanks. – atlantiza Dec 14 '12 at 4:31
  • @atlantiza: it's not - I just forgot to remove it from existing questions; thanks for the reminder! – Shog9 Dec 14 '12 at 4:34
  • @Shog9 Please also blacklist movie, light-novel, visual-novel, and live-action. I'm really not going to bother you again! – atlantiza Dec 14 '12 at 16:44
  • You can bother me any time, @atlantiza - but please make a separate meta post for these. – Shog9 Dec 14 '12 at 16:46
0

Why not create tags and ?

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .